CCNet 36/2002 - 18 March 2002

"I'm not going to be spooked or panicked into spending scarce
research dollars on a fruitless attempt to predict the next asteroid. I'm
just not convinced that the hype and alarm and even fear-mongering is
enough to justify an instant investment."
--Peter McGauran, Australian Minister for Science, 17 March

"One of the largest asteroids known to have approached the Earth
zipped past about 450,000 kilometres away on March 8 - but nobody
recorded it until four days later."
--Jeff Hecht, New Scientist, 15 March 2002

Yes 92%
No 8%

New Scientist, 15 March 2002

Sunday Sunrise, Australian Channel 7 TV, 17 March 2002

60 Minutes, 17 March, 2002


Der Spiegel, 15 March 2002

Sky & Telescope, 15 March 2002

Ron Baalke < >

Andrew Yee < >

Hermann Burchard < >

Ananova, 18 March 2002


>From New Scientist, 15 March 2002

One of the largest asteroids known to have approached the Earth zipped past
about 450,000 kilometres away on March 8 - but nobody recorded it until four
days later.

The object, now called 2002 EM7, was hard to spot because it was moving
outward from the innermost point of its orbit, 87 million km from the Sun.
When it passed closest to the Earth - just 1.5 times the distance to the
Moon - it was too close to the Sun to be visible.

Asteroids approaching from this blind spot cannot be seen by astronomers. If
a previously unknown object passed through this zone on a collision course
with Earth, it would not be identified until it was too late for any

Astronomers have made numerous calls in recent years for more funds to
catalogue near-Earth objects and refine their orbits. This would reduce the
number of unknown objects that could catch us unaware, and give early
warning of potential future collisions.

Bigger than Tunguska

An asteroid-hunting telescope operated by the MIT Lincoln Laboratory first
recorded the new asteroid on March 12, as it moved away from the Earth and
more of its bright side came into view.

Further observations allowed Timothy Spahr of the Harvard-Smithsonian Center
for Astrophysics to calculate its orbit. He found that it has a 323-day
orbit that takes it as far as 188 million km from the Sun.

Invisible to the unaided eye, 2002 EM7 is too small to be classed as a
"potentially hazardous asteroid". But it is probably between 50 to 100
metres across, making it larger than the object that exploded in 1908 over
the Tunguska region of Siberia, flattening trees over 2000 square

The approach puts it among the 10 closest known approaches by minor planets,
says Brian Marsden of Harvard-Smithsonian. More ominously, only one of the
10 closest objects was larger. This was 1996 JA1, which passed only slightly
closer to the Earth on 19 May 1996.

The discovery adds to the list of asteroids which are long shots to hit the
Earth in the next century. Preliminary calculations indicate 2002 EM7 has
Several chances to hit the Earth in that period, with odds of one in six
million to one in a billion, Marsden told New Scientist. Further
observations are likely to lengthen the odds.

Jeff Hecht

© Copyright Reed Business Information Ltd.


>From Sunday Sunrise, Australian Channel 7 TV, 17 March 2002

Australian scientists used to scour the sky for potentially dangerous
"near-Earth objects". But as John Collis reports, the Coalition government
cut funding for the "Spaceguard" program.
John Collis: It's half a lifetime since we slipped our mortal bonds where
the blue of the day meets the endless night.

And still it's hard to see our home for what it really is.

Spaceship Earth, on her eternal circuit of the Sun; our course charted in
chaos when the planets were born, lumbering along at 30 kilometres a second,
the road ahead anything but clear.

Dr Duncan Steel, Salford University, UK: We know now we live in a cosmic
shooting gallery. These things are whizzing by the Earth with alarming
frequency. This is something we had no idea about only 20 years ago.

John Collis: Cosmic rubble from marble-size to mountains, countless
thousands of asteroids swirling in a galactic mobile of chaotic orbits -
many routinely intersecting the Earth's. Often passing within a cosmic
whisker of disaster, and some preordained for catastrophe.

Professor Paul Davies, Macquarie University: Most of these things just come
out of the blue, there would be no warning from looking up into the sky
until it was already entering the atmosphere and then we're talking seconds
for it to reach the ground. We're talking about a million mega-tonne
explosion. That's a million city bursting bombs all going off at once.

John Collis: A scenario that for scale, tone and colour would usually ring
alarm bells in the reality-check department. But not when scientists of
international standing like Professor Paul Davies fire up with probabilities
translated into hair-raising odds.

Professor Paul Davies: We are talking here about something of devastating
proportions and there is about a one in a million chance of it happening
next month.

John Collis: Odds in statistical terms shorter than the chance of winning
Lotto suggesting by the same process we're more likely to die in an asteroid
impact than an airline crash.

Professor Paul Davies: We are talking here about a quantifiable threat. It
is still a small threat - and that's really important because I don't want
people to lie awake at night worrying about it but we are talking about,
say, a one in a 100,000 chance per year of an event like this happening.

John Collis: In geological terms, an event neither unprecedented nor rare,
our planet pockmarked with the evidence.

Massive craters like Wolfe Creek in Western Australia, a kilometre across,
punched in the desert by an asteroid of office block proportions 300,000
years ago.

The gaping Barringer Crater in Arizona, where disaster came out of the blue
just 50,000 years ago.

In living memory, the thousands of hectares of forest laid waste in 1908
when an incoming comet exploded over Siberia, the flash observed as far away
as England.

And identified in satellite scans, older and much bigger scars like this,
buried beneath Mexico's Yucatan peninsular. 300 kilometres across - possibly
the one that killed the dinosaurs and reset the Earth's evolutionary clock
65 million years ago.

A phenomenon once thought improbable, that unfolded before our eyes just
seven years back as fragments of a shattered comet slammed into our giant
solar sibling, Jupiter.

And for any doubters left, the wake-up call came last Christmas Eve when
NASA observers in Hawaii found a previously uncharted asteroid heading
straight for Earth.

YB5 they called it, a space mountain 300 metres wide, closing fast and
likely to pass between the Moon and Earth.

It was 40 hours before enough was known to recalculate in favour of Earth
and it slipped by on January 7th at roughly twice the Moon's distance.

That's still a miss by a whisker on the cosmic scale and, says Professor
Malcolm Walter of Macquarie University's department of Astrobiology, we
can't always be that lucky.

Professor Malcolm Walter: It is not funny and as we said before, it is going
to happen, it's just a matter of time.

John Collis: So science was well and truly on the case by the tllywood
cashed in, offering harrowing insight with films like Deep Impact.

And in that context of general growing awareness, an even more baffling

Dr Duncan Steel: We know how many are being missed and the answer is that
most are being missed.

John Collis: We go back six years to the Siding Springs Observatory scanning
the heavens from Coonabarabran in northwest New South Wales.

As the potential for global catastrophe dawned elsewhere, Australia's own
Spaceguard program, led by Dr Duncan Steel, had already been on finding and
charting intersecting asteroids for half a decade.

Abruptly and without explanation scuttled on the turn of the political tide
in 1996 by the incoming Howard Government.

And to continuing bewilderment of expanding search programmes in the
northern hemisphere, Spaceship Earth has been flying virtually blind on the
southern aspect ever since.

Dr Duncan Steel: In essence, one third of the sky is not being searched at

John Collis: And no one is more puzzled by that than the man who helped lay
the foundations.

Dr Duncan Steel: These things do happen, they don't happen often, but when
they do they have catastrophic consequences and because of that we have to
take them seriously, very seriously.

John Collis: It is now being taken seriously by many other countries. There
is only one country in the world which has ever had a big asteroid search
program and then closed it down - that's Australia.

Axed, it seems, for an annual saving of around 200,000 dollars, paltry in
the context of the total Federal spend.

And after six years bouncing off the bureaucratic brick wall, Michael Paine,
lobbying on behalf of the Planetary Society, still has no answer for the
fundamental question: Why was funding cut?

Michael Paine, volunteer, Planetary Society: Here's all these ministerial
portfolios, "it's not mine, it's not mine" and nobody will come to grips
with it.

John Collis: What remains of the Australian effort is scattered and almost
as elusive as the faint images marking a potential near-Earth hazard.

Gordon Garradd, astronomer: Well I'm not going to save the Earth. I'm just
going to help map out what's there and what the risk is. I'll leave it to
others to work out what they are and what they are going to do about it.

John Collis: On his private mountain in the New England Ranges of northern
New South Wales, Gordon Garradd drives his home-made telescope from the back
of his wagon.

A far cry from the mighty instrument he worked with Duncan Steel at Siding
Springs but powerful enough to cover crucial gaps for NASA as objects of
interest dip beyond range of northern observatories.

Gordon Garradd: The orbits do move around quite a lot so you have got to
keep track of them otherwise they get lost and you don't know where they are
and that's the main worry at the moment.

John Collis: One of just three part-timers retained by other nations to keep
watch from Australia.

Dr Duncan Steel: It really is ridiculous. It is almost a Dad's Army approach
to the defence of the world.

John Collis: Now back in Britain, Duncan Steel has his theories about what
went wrong, favouring an astonishing conspiracy of political ignorance and
professional skulduggery brought on by his own media profile.

Dr Duncan Steel: The problem is your fellow scientists. They get so jealous,
they tell a pack of lies as happened in this case, which means that in the
end your entire program gets cut.

John Collis: And when you look at the big picture of our scientific
endeavour, the mystery only deepens because Australia is and long has been
in the forefront of astronomical research.

This facility at Narrabri, for instance, is the most sophisticated in the
southern hemisphere. And what was it doing when the latest threat emerged
from space. It was doing the thing that interests big science: peering at
objects at the known limits of the universe.

Professor Paul Davies: There are always two theories of history of course,
aren't there. There's the conspiracy theory and the cock-up theory. I always
favour the cock-up theory.

John Collis: A budgetary item too small to attract attention, says Paul

More practical than theoretical, more defence than science, simply lost
somewhere in the "too hard basket".

But the failure to put things right richly deserving of international scorn.

Professor Paul Davies: I think Australia's name is mud among the people who
care about this particular issue.

John Collis: And, he says, even criminal.

Professor Paul Davies: If you stand back and say we are wilfully ignoring
the greatest ecological threat to the planet, I'd say criminal.

Copyright 2002, Sunday Sunrise


>From 60 Minutes, 17 March, 2002

Reporter: Liz Hayes Producers: Gareth Harvey, Sallie Stone

Join our live chat with Dr Duncan Steele and Michael Paine from the
Planetary Society of Australian Volunteers on Sunday March 17 @ 8:30-9.30pm
AEDST. Click here.

A few weeks ago, Liz Hayes visited the site of an asteroid strike in Central
Australia. If a similar asteroid were to strike today, it'd be curtains for
us all.

The scenario is more real than most of us realise. A third of all asteroids
hitting earth's atmosphere do so over our southern skies.

So, imagine the fury of Australia's scientists when the Federal Government
stopped funding "Spaceguard", a world's best program at tracking asteroids.

The government claims there's nothing to worry about, but scientists warn
it's left us blind to the threat from above.


LIZ HAYES: A few weeks ago, I visited the site of an ancient asteroid strike
in central Australia. It's spectacular and very, very daunting. If a similar
asteroid were to strike today, it would be curtains for us all. So imagine
the fury of scientists when the Federal Government stopped funding
Spaceguard, one of the world's leading programs tracking asteroids. The
government says there's nothing to worry about, but scientists warn this
leaves us blind to the threat.


LIZ HAYES: This is Hollywood's version of an asteroid slamming into earth.
Scientists insist this is pure film-maker's fantasy. The reality will be
far, far worse.

DR DUNCAN STEEL: Since the end of the Cold War, there's only one thing left
which could cause a global catastrophe, which could wipe us all out, or send
us back into the Dark Ages, and that's an asteroid hitting the Earth.

BRIAN BOYLE: I don't know. Perhaps this is just nature's way of giving us
the flick.

LIZ HAYES: Our planet is being stalked. The enemy is any one of the
thousands of giant chunks of rock whose passage through space could lead to
a collision with Earth.

DR DUNCAN STEEL: The reality is, right now as I sit here speaking to you, I
know there are asteroids bigger than 50m or 60m in size which are closer to
the Earth than the Moon.

LIZ HAYES: Astronomer Duncan Steel has dedicated his life to hunting
asteroids. He says we're seriously ill-prepared for this threat from space.

DR DUNCAN STEEL: You never know. It could be tomorrow. It could be right now
as we're speaking that, in fact, one has entered the atmosphere above
Sydney. And if a 50m or 60m rock enters above Sydney, everywhere has had it.

LIZ HAYES: Asteroids can be as small as pebbles and as big as planets. Their
numbers are infinite and they're hitting Earth all the time. Most burn up in
the atmosphere, like this one filmed in the '70s. But the big ones get
through. This is Wolf Creek Crater in WA. If I'd been standing here 300,000
years ago, I would have seen what probably looked like a bright shooting
star in the eastern sky. We now know it was a small asteroid, travelling at
about 15km kilometres per second. It crossed over eastern Australia in five
minutes. I would not have been alive to witness the final moments of its
collision, but even today the scale of that impact is simply breathtaking.

PAUL DAVIES: This crater here was blasted in the Australian Outback by the
impact of an object about the size of a small office block and flattened
everything in an area maybe up to 1000 square kilometres around, so one hell
of a bang.

LIZ HAYES: Paul Davies is another Australian astro-biologist trying to sound
the alarm.

PAUL DAVIES: This is just a lottery, these objects don't come on cue. It's
totally random. There are many more smaller ones than big ones and so
explosions of the magnitude that produced this crater here will occur on
average perhaps every few hundred years.

LIZ HAYES: Paul Davies believes Australia is lucky that so far asteroids
have only hit in the Outback. But more are coming. It's not a matter of if,
but when.

PAUL DAVIES: Definitely when, because it's not going to stop now. This
bombardment has been going on throughout geological history and it's going
to continue.

DR DUNCAN STEEL: It is true that Australians on the average are at greater
risk because we tend to live around the coast. If you live around the coast,
you're facing on to big targets. The Indian Ocean, the Pacific Ocean in
particular is a big target, and a decent asteroid going plonk into the
middle of the Pacific is going to cause a tsunami which is going to take
out, in essence, all of the cities along the east coast.

PAUL DAVIES: A tsunami rises up off the shore over there to several hundred
metres. It would come straight across Sydney Heads, crashing through the
harbour here, over the top of the Harbour Bridge - it would take out that -
the whole CBD and then it would surge on into those suburbs beyond. Millions
would perish, no doubt about that.

LIZ HAYES: And if an asteroid actually hit the city?

PAUL DAVIES: It would flatten the whole city with the blast wave and it
would send a shock wave into the surrounding countryside and cause damage
for tens of kilometres. If it were to explode in the air above the ground,
as they often do, the devastation could be even worse.

LIZ HAYES: It has happened. Sixty-five million years ago, an asteroid wiped
out nearly all life on earth. The impact and the aftermath left dinosaurs

DR DUNCAN STEEL: When we're talking about a decent-sized asteroid, let's say
1km across, hitting the earth, you're talking about energy being released
which is far in excess of all the world's nuclear arsenals put together.
Quite clearly, something hitting the earth which kills millions, perhaps
billions of people, is going to cause a total disintegration of the society
which we currently know.

WOMAN: We have lift-off of the Delta rocket carrying the 'Nero' spacecraft,
bound for the asteroid Eros.

LIZ HAYES: For the past decade, NASA has sent cameras into space to learn
more about asteroids. Along with dozens of other countries, America is
constantly searching and tracking asteroids. Last year, they even landed on
an asteroid called Eros. These are the images they saw. But who is watching
over the southern skies? Does Australia know what deep space is throwing our

DR DUNCAN STEEL: We believe there are something like 1200 asteroids bigger
than about 1km in size on Earth-crossing orbits - potential impacters of the
Earth. We've found about half of them. The ones that are dangerous to us at
the moment are those we haven't seen yet. People think we have got all these
things mapped and that's the problem. That's what we keep saying. We haven't
yet found all these objects. They think that there's these batteries of
telescopes scouring the skies and there just aren't, you know. We always say
there's less people working on looking for asteroids worldwide than works in
the average McDonald's. That's the way it is.

LIZ HAYES: In 1996, the Howard government withdrew all money for what was
known as Spaceguard, our part in the global response to the asteroid menace.
But since then, despite repeated pleas by the international scientific
community, the government has refused to renew the funding, effectively
leaving us blind to what might be passing through the southern skies. The
Spaceguard program, led by Duncan Steel, had identified 30 percent of known
asteroids. Steel now teaches in England and no-one is keeping watch over

DR DUNCAN STEEL: Australia in this area is a pariah. It's regarded as being
a total outcast. It is the only country ever to have closed down a
successful asteroid program when all the other countries are gearing up.

PETER McGAURAN: I'm not going to be spooked or panicked into spending scarce
research dollars on a fruitless attempt to predict the next asteroid.

LIZ HAYES: Peter McGauran is the Minister for Science. He axed the
Spaceguard program, taking Australia out of astronomy's version of
Neighbourhood Watch.

PETER McGAURAN: We spend about $18 million a year on astronomy and that's a
significant investment by Australia, particularly by worldwide standards. I
wouldn't like to divert up to five or more percent of that budget towards a
fruitless, unnecessary, self-indulgent exercise.

LIZ HAYES: Self-indulgent because scientists like Duncan Steel think it
should be done?

PETER McGAURAN: How many others agree with them? I know they've gathered
together a number of scientific generalists. I want the astronomers
themselves, under the supervision of an objective worldwide working party,
making a true and proper assessment. I'm just not convinced that the hype
and alarm and even fear-mongering is enough to justify an instant

DR DUNCAN STEEL: A letter went to Mr Howard last week with 91 signatories,
in essence a roll call of all the world's experts in this area saying,
"Please, we need Australia to be involved. You are the most technologically
developed country in the Southern Hemisphere. We need you to be involved in

PETER McGAURAN: I lie awake worrying about a lot of other things. Near-miss
asteroids is not one of them.

BRIAN BOYLE: Who are you going to get to guard the planet? A bunch of
astronomers or a bunch of scientists? I don't think so. It is clearly,
firmly, a Defence matter.

LIZ HAYES: Brian Boyle is Director of the Anglo Australian Observatory in
Sydney. He says what's the point of tracking asteroids if there's nothing
you can do to stop them?

BRIAN BOYLE: My colleagues are very well-intentioned and I have the greatest
of respect for these people and they're right to identify it as an issue,
but frankly, I think that a threat that exists without a credible response
policy, as the asteroid threat indeed is, is not looking at the full
picture. Please, don't lose any sleep. The asteroid is not necessarily going
to come and get you tomorrow.

DR DUNCAN STEEL: The name of the game is: map all these objects out there,
determine their orbits, mini-orbits, before they going to come back and hit
the Earth, and then be able to say, "Hey, look, this one here. That one's a
danger to us."

LIZ HAYES: And, says Steel, there are ways we can save ourselves if we have
enough warning. Not quite Deep Impact, but using nuclear weapons to deflect
an incoming asteroid well ahead of impact time.

DR DUNCAN STEEL: The dinosaurs did not have a space program. That's why they
died. We need to have a space program in order to save ourselves from the
next asteroid impact. It isn't a matter of if one of these things is going
to hit the Earth. It's just a matter of when. Either we can expect 23 years
warning or six or seven seconds. Okay. The most likely answer at the current
time is six or seven seconds. We'll be aware of the asteroid which is going
to hit us as it enters the atmosphere and all of a sudden lights up far, far
brighter than the sun.

LIZ HAYES: And that would be it? That's it. You can kiss everything goodbye.

© 1997-2001 ninemsn Pty Ltd - All rights reserved


>From, 16 March 2002

Rio, 16 de Março de 2002

Asteróide passa de raspão pela Terra

LONDRES. Um asteróide grande o suficiente para destruir cidades passou perto
da Terra na semana passada, mas só foi detectado depois que já se afastava
do planeta. O incidente reacendeu a discussão sobre a necessidade de
melhorar o sistema de rastreamento de asteróides e cometas potencialmente

O asteróide, batizado de 2002 EM7, passou a 450 mil quilômetros do planeta -
o equivalente a uma vez e meia a distância da Terra à Lua - no último dia 8.
Só foi notado por astrônomos quatro dias depois. O astro estava no ponto de
sua órbita mais próximo do Sol, a 87 mil quilômetros apenas, e a
interferência da luz solar impedia que ele fosse visto da Terra.

Asteróides que se aproximam por esse ponto cego não podem ser vistos pelos
astrônomos. Se um objeto desconhecido passar por essa zona em rota de
colisão com a Terra, não seria identificado a tempo de se lançar um alerta.
Nos últimos anos, os cientistas já fizeram numerosos pedidos de verbas para
que consigam catalogar astros próximos à Terra e detalhar suas órbitas.

Invisível a olho nu, o asteróide tem entre 50 e cem metros - maior do que o
astro que caiu, em 1908, na Sibéria, derrubando árvores numa área de cerca
de 2.000 quilômetros quadrados.


>From Der Spiegel, 15 March 2002,1518,187243,00.html

Hobby-Astronom entdeckt erdnahen Asteroiden

Ein Essener Freizeitforscher hat einen Kleinplaneten entdeckt, der als
potenziell gefährlich eingestuft wurde. Groß ist das Risiko eines
Zusammenpralls aber nicht.

Der Asteroid, der die Bezeichnung 2002 EL6 erhielt, kreuzt die Bahn der
Erde. Nach Angaben der US-Raumfahrtbehörde Nasa liegt die Wahrscheinlichkeit
einer Kollision in diesem Jahrhundert jedoch nur bei etwa eins zu 30
Millionen. Das Minor Planet Center, ein Erfassungsprogramm für Kleinplaneten
am Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory, listet derzeit 386 solcher
Asteroiden auf potenziell gefährlichen Bahnen auf.

Der Essener Amateur-Astronom entdeckte 2002 EL6 am 11. März als
Gastbeobachter an der Sternwarte Drebach in Sachsen. Das Minor Planet Center
habe den Kleinplaneten anschließend als potenziell gefährlich eingestuft,
teilte die Sternwarte Bochum am Freitag mit.

Copyright 2002, Der Spiegel


>From Sky & Telescope, 15 March 2002

By J. Kelly Beatty

March 15, 2002 | During the mid-1970s, fortuitous geometry allowed Mariner
10 to zip by Mercury three times in a 12-month period. But that same
geometry precluded the spacecraft from seeing almost half of the innermost
planet's surface - a "terra incognita" that remains virtually unknown nearly
three decades later.

However, as radar facilities on Earth continue to probe the unseen territory
with ever-improving resolution, Mercury is slowly giving up its secrets.
Several days of observations made last June and July with the 305-meter
Arecibo dish in Puerto Rico recorded details only a few kilometers across
and turned up a number of surprises.

Nearly straddling the equator on Mercury's unseen hemisphere is a prominent,
85-kilometer-wide crater sitting in a splash of bright rays some 900 km
across. According to John K. Harmon (National Astronomy and Ionosphere
Center) and Donald B. Campbell (Cornell), the rays are extremely rough -
jumbles of rock and dust thrown out by the impact - which makes them
excellent reflectors of Arecibo's radar pulses. The rays look so fresh, in
fact, that this crater may be much younger than similarly sized Tycho, which
was blasted out of the lunar landscape 109 million years ago. Harmon notes
that the unnamed Mercurian crater had been seen in previous radar campaigns,
but with only a tenth as much resolution.

Fortunately, two new spacecraft will soon be en route to mysterious Mercury.
NASA's mission, MESSENGER, calls for a heavily instrumented craft to slip
into orbit around the planet in April 2009 and conduct comprehensive mapping
surveys and compositional assays. That same year the European Space Agency
plans to dispatch its BepiColombo spacecraft, which honors Italian space
scientist Guiseppe "Bepi" Colombo (1920-1984). Upon arrival at Mercury after
a 2½-year flight, it will separate into one orbiter to study the globe, a
second orbiter to monitor the magnetic field, and a small lander to analyze
the surface rocks.

Copyright 2002 Sky Publishing Corp.


>From Ron Baalke < >

Stargazer finds comet
Sierra Vista Herald
March 14, 2002

PALOMINAS - With his eyes on the skies and the strains of "Some Enchanted
Evening" playing in the background, Doug Snyder made the discovery of a
lifetime early Monday morning.

The amateur stargazer discovered a new comet streaking through the Aquila
Constellation in the heart of the Summer Milky Way galaxy.

At 3:40 on Monday morning, he happened across "a little gray smudge" nestled
in the Aquila Constellation. He did some quick research using a sky atlas
and numerous databases, but couldn't locate any references to his find.

Trying not to get his hopes too high, Snyder checked the comet's location
again. "The comet had moved a bit, but not too much, and I found it again
fairly easily. Dawn was coming, and my view of the comet was fading, but by
now I was becoming more sure of my discovery," Snyder said.

He immediately e-mailed news of his discovery to the Central Bureau for
Astronomical Telegrams, the Harvard-affiliated clearinghouse for new
discoveries. It was 4 a.m. and the world was being told the latest space
find had been made at a small observatory in Southeastern Arizona.

Several anxious hours later, he received a reply. CBAT has spent the interim
time researching his find, verifying Snyder's experience and credentials,
and locating the comet. CBAT asked for additional information, which Snyder
provided, and then he waited.

"It's been a whirlwind couple of days," Snyder said. "But yesterday
(Tuesday), they finally let me know that I had really discovered a new

Full story here:


>From Andrew Yee < >

Marketing & Communications
University of Calgary
Calgary, Alberta

Dennis Urquhart, Media Relations
(403) 220-7722

March 5, 2002

8.2-kilogram Manitoba meteorite is second largest of its kind in Canada

A large rock that a Manitoba man found while grading a road has been
identified as Canada's newest meteorite by the Prairie Meteorite Search, a
national project led by the Universities of Calgary, Regina, and Western

The Elm Creek meteorite, weighing 8.2 kilograms, is the second-largest stony
meteorite ever found in Canada and is Manitoba's largest. It is the fifth
meteorite to be recovered in Manitoba (Manitoba is now tied with Quebec for
recoveries), and is the 61st Canadian discovery. It is also the first time
that a meteorite has been found in Canada with a road grader.

Tom Wood (right) unearthed the big rock while grading a dirt road to the
southeast of Elm Creek, Manitoba during late August 1997. "It seemed to be
too heavy to be a normal stone," Wood recalls. "I thought then that it might
be a meteorite, but I was half kidding when I told my wife so later that

The recovered stone is a broken piece with scrape marks on it, presumably
from road grading. The other half of the meteorite, estimated to weigh about
five kilograms, is thought to be still embedded in the dirt road. Mr. Wood is not sure
exactly where he recovered the first piece, so the recovery of the remainder is in doubt.

Dan Lockwood, a U of C student, was the Prairie Meteorite Searcher for the
summer of 2001. The Elm Creek meteorite was his second discovery among about
600 samples of possible meteorites that he looked at. He was holding a rock
identification clinic in the Co-op store in Carman, Manitoba, when Mr. Wood brought
the rock in.

"The rock was covered in dirt, but its density made it deserving of a wash
and a closer look," Lockwood (left) says. "After washing I had suspicions
that the rock was indeed a meteorite, but I flip-flopped back and forth for
more than three weeks over whether or not it was genuine."

The meteorite was eventually confirmed when Lockwood returned to the
University of Calgary at the end of his field season. It is a well-weathered
rock and probably fell to Earth thousands of years ago. Most of its fusion
crust is weathered off revealing an interior that shows cracks from the
shattering of its parent asteroid.

Dr. Alan Hildebrand, holder of a Canada Research Chair in Planetary Sciences
at the U of C and one of the project leaders, praises Mr. Wood for his
efforts in bringing the specimen to the attention of scientists. "I am
frankly amazed at Mr. Wood's perceptiveness in noting that this dirt-covered
rock was unusual. It goes to show what a lifetime of experience and healthy
curiosity can do to one's perceptions," Hildebrand says. Research will help
classify the stone and determine if it was part of a larger fall.

The Prairie Meteorite Search field campaign locates meteorites by
encouraging Prairie farmers to have rocks identified that they suspect may
be meteorites. The project consists of local publicity and visits by the
searcher to towns to show meteorite specimens and to identify possible
meteorites. The project relies on people having seen meteorites and the
possibility of immediate identification to make discoveries.

"More than a dozen unconfirmed new meteorites are thought to be in the hands
of farming families across the prairies," says Lockwood, who is now back
studying at the University of Calgary. "The Prairie Meteorite Search found
two new meteorites during each of the summers of 2000 and 2001, but a better
means of reaching farmers who have rocks to be identified should be able to
increase the recovery rate."

The Prairie Meteorite Search project leaders are Dr. Alan Hildebrand,
University of Calgary; Dr. Peter Brown, The University of Western Ontario,
and Dr. Martin Beech, University of Regina. They are all members of the
Meteorites and Impacts Advisory Committee to the Canadian Space Agency. This
is Canada's volunteer group charged with the investigation of fireballs and
the recovery of meteorites. Project funding for the summer project of 2001
came from the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council's
Undergraduate Student Research Award Program, the international Meteoritical
Society, and other grants held by the project leaders.

Potential meteorites may be identified by contacting:

* in Manitoba -- George Clark at Dept. of Geological Sciences,
University of Manitoba (204) 474-8857
* in Saskatchewan -- Martin Beech at Campion College, University of
Regina (306) 359-1216.
* in Alberta -- Alan Hildebrand at Dept. of Geology and Geophysics,
University of Calgary, (403) 220-2291.

Additional contact information for the project is located at this Web

For Media:
Mr. Tom Wood may be contacted at (204) 745-7132 at (204) 436-2332.

Dan Lockwood can be reached via Alan Hildebrand at (403) 220-2291 or Dennis
Urquhart (403) 220-7722.

High-resolution images of Mr. Wood and/or Dan Lockwood can be obtained from
Dennis Urquhart at (403) 220-7722 or

[NOTE: Images supporting this release are available at ]



>From Hermann Burchard < >

Dear Benny,

the journal SCIENCE, March 15, has an article "Mammalian Dispersal at the
Paleocene/Eocene Boundary", dispersal being shown by the authors to have
proceeded out of Asia into North America and Europe. (See copy of abstract

Is this not evidence for regional extinction at the K/T boundary? After one
or more cosmogenic impacts, survivors likely remained in areas that were the
most remote from impact sites. Mention is made in the abstract of primates
(not of Africa). Evidence for primates in Africa before 25 Ma ago, when
Africa-Arabia collided with Asia does not seem very strong (the full article
may cover these points).

Another SCIENCE article earlier this month could be said to have lent
support to the regional extinction idea: "Flight of the Dodo." Beth
Shapiro, Dean Sibthorpe, Andrew Rambaut, Jeremy Austin, Graham M. Wragg,
Olaf R. P. Bininda- Emonds, Patricia L. M. Lee, and Alan Cooper. Science
Mar 1 2002: 1683. This was widely reported in media, e.g.:

The flightless Dodo, as is shown there from DNA analysis, was a pigeon
standing three feet tall that became isolated genetically after flying to
the Mascarene group of islands, to which Maurititius belongs about 42 Ma ago
at the end of the Eocene. Its nearest relatives today live in SE Asia and
Australasia, ranging from the Nicobars to Samoa.

Of course, from plate tectonics we know that Mauritius at 42 Ma would have
been nearer to where the Seychelles are now, and both were closer to India,
which then had just begun to collide with the main continent of Asia.
Rifting along the Carlsberg Ridge continues to cause seafloor spreading.
Australasia and the Nicobars, too, would have been closer to Mauritius at
that time.

There would seem to be more evidence here for regional extinction and
subsequent dispersal of birds as well as mammals from areas far from K/T
impact sites in the Yucatan (Chicxulub crater, widely accepted) and Bombay-
Seychelles-Amirante (Shiva crater, controversial). The latter split the
Earth's crust along the Carlsberg Ridge and left the Reunion Island volcano
near Mauritius.

Those ancestral pigeons flew into the devastated lands around the Shiva
crater perhaps being among the first colonists, growing genetically isolated
from their Eastern cousins some 23 Ma after the impacts.

Recently, K/T gradualism was discussed by Jan Smit and Gerta Keller, CCNet
February 1, 2. I rather suspect this may be a case of possible multiple
impacts at time intervals alleged to be millions of years causing regional
extinctions. Any actual gradualism (as opposed to multiple impacts and
regionalism) I believe was disproved by Peter Sheehan, Milwaukee, whose
teams carefully surveyed the abundance of dinosaurs in the uppermost
Cretaceous strata of South Dakota and Montana, finding Tyrannosaur and
Triceratops up to the very extinction layer. To me, this looks like sudden
extinction of these key Cretaceous genera (I don't think he deserves the
criticism that he has received from some quarters).

Regionally some dinosaurs survived --! After all, birds were dinosaurs of a
sort, as we know from Mongolian feather-clad non-avian dinosaurs found
recently. We can picture a feathered T. rex, flapping stubby wings darting
about for morsels much like birds do, but incapable of a sustained run.

Best regards,

Mammalian Dispersal at the Paleocene/Eocene Boundary

Gabriel J. Bowen,1* William C. Clyde,2 Paul L. Koch,1 Suyin Ting,34 John
Alroy,5 Takehisa Tsubamoto,6 Yuanqing Wang,4 Yuan Wang4

A profound faunal reorganization occurred near the Paleocene/Eocene
boundary, when several groups of mammals abruptly appeared on the Holarctic
continents. To test the hypothesis that this event featured the dispersal of
groups from Asia to North America and Europe, we used isotope stratigraphy,
magnetostratigraphy, and quantitative biochronology to constrain the
relative age of important Asian faunas. The extinct family Hyaenodontidae
appeared in Asia before it did so in North America, and the modern orders
Primates, Artiodactyla, and Perissodactyla first appeared in
Asia at or before the Paleocene/Eocene boundary. These results are
consistent with Asia being a center for early mammalian origination.

1 Department of Earth Sciences, University of California, Santa Cruz, CA
95064, USA.
2 Department of Earth Sciences, University of New Hampshire, Durham, NH
03824-3589, USA.
3 Museum of Natural Science, Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, LA
70803, USA.
4 Institute of Vertebrate Paleontology and Paleoanthropology, Chinese
Academy of Sciences, Post Office Box 643, Beijing 100044, People's Republic
of China.
5 National Center for Ecological Analysis and Synthesis, University of
California, Santa Barbara, CA 93101-3351, USA.
6 Primate Research Institute, Kyoto University, Inuyama 484-8506, Japan.

* To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail:


>From Ananova, 18 March 2002

Nasa researchers say company bosses should allow their workers to fall
asleep at their desks.

Studies have shown that performance increases by 35% if employees take a
45-minute "power nap" in the afternoon.

Scientists says the Mediterranean-style siesta should be adopted by any
business looking to increase its productivity.

The nap even improves the ability to judge business decisions correctly by
50%, it's claimed.

Nasa carried out the research to find out how best to make use of
astronauts' time in space.

But they also found the same was true for office workers with less glamorous
or demanding jobs.

Mark Rosekind, of California-based Alertness Solutions, told The Times: "It
is a false myth that if you spend more hours awake you are more productive."

CCNet is a scholarly electronic network. To subscribe/unsubscribe, please
contact the moderator Benny J Peiser < >. Information
circulated on this network is for scholarly and educational use only. The
attached information may not be copied or reproduced for any other purposes
without prior permission of the copyright holders. The fully indexed archive
of the CCNet, from February 1997 on, can be found at .
DISCLAIMER: The opinions, beliefs and viewpoints expressed in the articles
and texts and in other CCNet contributions do not necessarily reflect the
opinions, beliefs and viewpoints of the moderator of this network.

CCCMENU CCC for 2002